As studies have shown, among the consequences of ubiquitous, shamelessly extolled hatred of Jews and of Israel, these past three years and more, has been a surge in the search by many Jews for a more sustaining, supportive, framework of Jewish life.
One manifestation of such a search has been by parents seeking immersive Jewish education for their children. Many of the seekers however, stumble over a very high hurdle: the cost of tuition.
We are familiar with that hurdle. It was the springboard for the founding of GAJE more than a decade ago. Thankfully, community philanthropists and Federation planners and officials took steps some years ago, to knock that hurdle down a few notches. The costs of tuition in the GTA are still high. But more families have found a way to enter the system because in their minds, the situation today compels them to try. Schools and “the community” follow closely, and attempt meaningfully, to respond to the increasing demand for spaces in the day schools. The day school situation here is “more advanced” than in many jurisdictions in the U.S.
In a forceful cri de coeur published this week by the JTA, Judah Taub, the author of Moonshots for Israel, pleads for affordable day school tuition. His article’s purpose is evident from its title: The Jewish tax: To preserve a Jewish future, lower the cost of raising Jewish kids.
Taub restates the broad observations that many others have made over the years – including here – regarding high day school tuition. “The very wealthy can afford this. Lower-income families may qualify for significant assistance. The people trapped in the middle are … two professionals earning what sounds like an excellent American income until someone asks them to find another $100,000, after tax, every September.” Taub writes that “Middle class families cannot afford upwards of $100,000 a year to keep their Jewish children Jewish.” Of course, he is correct.
He deftly characterizes the impact of high day school tuition. “We have, in effect, created a Jewish tax: an additional price attached to choosing a fuller Jewish life…..No subsidy can manufacture Jewish identity. Family, friendship, community and belief matter enormously. But saying money doesn’t play a role is simply not true.”
Taub makes his case on the basis of mathematical analysis as well as on his sense of belonging to the Jewish people. “In Jewish Toronto, after eight years of declining enrollment, a 2017 initiative brought tuition down to CA$18,500 from CA$28,000, and enrollment nearly doubled…The effect compounds. My own modeling, based on these results, suggests that if enrollment in Jewish institutions doubled across the Diaspora, the odds that a non-Orthodox child would stay connected to Jewish life as an adult would rise by nearly 14 percentage points. That would mean hundreds of thousands of additional Jews within a single generation. This isn’t only about who signs up for school. It’s about who’s still here decades from now.”
Taub raises no new arguments in pleading for lower day school tuitions. But he does marshal facts in newer comparative formats. For example, he provides a chart showing the cost of raising a Jewish child in 8 large cities around the world, (including Toronto), factoring in the costs of kashrut, summer camp, synagogues and day school. He also compiles a chart showing the projected trend of non-Orthodox Jews in North America to the year 2075.
Taub pleads. We should “stop making Jewish life unnecessarily difficult to choose.” Or at least show that we are earnestly trying. The hour demands no less.
The article is available at: https://www.jta.org/2026/11/17/ideas/the-jewish-tax-to-preserve-a-jewish-future-lower-the-cost-of-raising-jewish-kids
•••
The Supreme Court has not yet decided whether GAJE’s application for fairness in educational funding in Ontario can proceed. When it finally decides, we will publish the court’s decision at our first opportunity.
•••
If you wish to contribute to GAJE’s lawsuit to achieve fairness in educational funding, please click here. Charitable receipts for donations for income tax purposes will be issued by Mizrachi Canada. Your donations will be used for the sole purpose of helping to underwrite the costs of the lawsuit. For further information, please contact Israel Mida at: imida1818@gmail.com Thank you, in advance, for considering doing so.
•••
Shabbat shalom
Grassroots for Affordable Jewish Education
November 20, 2026