Since GAJE believes that Jewish education – in all its forms – is vital, we have informed readers of the progress of ADRABA, the innovative, creative, responsive, online Jewish school that provides a hands-on, for-credit, unique learning experience.

We are therefore again delighted to report that on October 16, ADRABA will begin its fourth year. By any measure, the school has been a success. It is being noticed by educators, parents and students in communities around the country.

One grateful student wrote of his experience: “I just wanted to thank you for such an amazing year. I truly had the most wonderful time being able to engage in things that interested me and am forever grateful for your engaging ways of teaching as well as your flexibility for submitting things in ways I felt I could express myself. In addition, your flexibility and willingness to accommodate my schedule will be forever remembered and appreciated.”

With increasingly supportive winds billowing strength and confidence into the young school’s sails, ADRABA continues to move forward. It advises that it will continue to serve communities outside the GTA, in Sudbury, Kingston and Ancaster while hoping to reach students in Thunder Bay. It will also continue to offer a course on Canadian history in person at the Paul Penna Downtown Jewish Day School in Toronto.

In its upcoming fourth year, ADRABA will bring back its former Grade 12, University level course, Philosophy, which will introduce students to classic thinkers in dialogue with Jewish counterparts: Aristotle with Maimonides and Locke alongside Mendelssohn. It will also introduce a new course in Media Studies that aims to provide teens with a deeper understanding of how legacy and new media and social media operate, as well as how to identify bias and misinformation – particularly when it comes to Israel-Palestine.

Sholom Eisenstat, one of the school’s co-founders, notes “ADRABA engages teens in adult-level learning that deals with sophisticated topics and challenging content – which normalizes Jewish learning as something that Jews just do.”

“ADRABA is working to create opportunities for Jewish teens across the province to acquire the building blocks [for living a Jewish life] – and more,” Eisenstat wrote last year. “Our online courses, for high school credit, are modelled on the Ontario high school curriculum and enhanced with quality Jewish content, interactive media, and challenging ideas. We add Jewish content infused with the best technological learning tools to deliver engaging and informative, live, interactive lessons and assignments. And we deliver it to teens from Cambridge to Kingston, and from Spadina Avenue to Sudbury.”

We hope and trust that ADRABA succeeds – by thinking out of the proverbial box – in reaching more and more students across the country.

To learn more about ADRABA, visit their website https://www.adraba.ca

•••

We still await the decision of Judge Papageorgiou on the motion brought by the governments of Ontario and Canada to strike our application. As soon as we know her decision, we will share it with you.

If you wish to support GAJE’s lawsuit for fairness in educational funding, please click here.

For further information, please contact Israel Mida at: imida1818@gmail.com

Charitable receipts for donations for income tax purposes will be issued by Mizrachi Canada. Your donations will be used for the sole purpose of underwriting the costs of the lawsuit.

•••

Shabbat shalom

Grassroots for Affordable Jewish Education (GAJE)

July 21, 2023

In a recent communication to the community, UJA Federation of Greater Toronto reported that enrolment in day school education continues to grow. According to the Federation, more than 800 new students have been added to UJA’s partner day schools since 2017, at the elementary and high school level in the non-Orthodox sector.

This is a major positive development to be cheered and to be encouraged further. Therefore, as families make plans for their children’s education in 2023-3024, it is timely to remind everyone of the availability of the community’s endowment fund – The Generations Trust – specifically earmarked to help enable young families enrol their children in Jewish day schools. (For more information on The Generations Trust, contact UJA Federation of Greater Toronto.)

In the same vein, on the subject of helping to enable young families to enrol their children in Jewish day schools, we still await a decision on the attempt by the governments of Ontario and Canada to strike our application for educational funding fairness. But in the matter of GAJE’s legal case, a reminder to readers is also timely.

On April 20, Ontario and Canada argued in court that our case should be dismissed out of hand for the reason that the issue was resolved in 1996 (the Adler decision) and that decision should still stand without any regard to the circumstances that have intervened in nearly three subsequent decades.

How does GAJE answer that? Why, after all, does GAJE believe it is appropriate in 2023 to ask the court to reassess the decision of 1996 that allowed Ontario to discriminate in favour of one religion only in its educational funding?

There are a number of reasons.

First, GAJE’s application to the court raises legal issues which the Supreme Court did not decide in Adler. Therefore, the Adler decision is not a precedent binding on the court in relation to these new legal issues.  

Second, insofar as the Adler decision does apply, the Supreme Court has shown a willingness, in the last decade, to re-examine previous decisions under limited circumstances. That is, where a new legal issue is raised or where there is a change in the circumstances or evidence that fundamentally shifts the parameters of the debate. Both criteria exist in GAJE’s application.

Third, rights-based claims, such as GAJE’s case, which impact large groups, should be heard on their merits and not dismissed at the first instance without a substantive hearing. Striking down a claim about government policy and legislation, rather than addressing its rights-based merits, impacts the ability of Ontario’s Jewish parents to continue to provide the educational opportunities to their children that Roman Catholic parents have. This reduces the ability of the Jewish community to flourish and thrive in a meaningful way.

Where discrimination is perpetuated by the government on an ongoing, obviously prima facie basis, a just and human rights-respecting society should periodically review whether the continuation of such discrimination remains justified. Have circumstances changed since the discrimination was originally authorized? Has the law evolved in any relevant respect since the discrimination was first enshrined into the law? Should not the governments – of their own accord for the sake of doing the right thing – wish to re-examine their behavior in light of the passage of nearly three decades?

In short, should the discrimination that was permitted in 1996 still be permitted in 2023?

Why does the government refuse to even allow this question to be raised? We believe the courts should not only be allowed to answer this question but that indeed, they should want to compel the government to answer it too.

•••

We still await the decision of Judge Papageorgiou on the motion brought by the governments of Ontario and Canada to strike our application. As soon as we know her decision, we will share it with you.

If you wish to support GAJE’s lawsuit for fairness in educational funding, please click here.

For further information, please contact Israel Mida at: imida1818@gmail.com

Charitable receipts for donations for income tax purposes will be issued by Mizrachi Canada. Your donations will be used for the sole purpose of underwriting the costs of the lawsuit.

•••

Shabbat shalom

Grassroots for Affordable Jewish Education (GAJE)

July 14, 2023

The CJN reported last week that the government of Ontario has announced it will enable families to have access to faith-based daycares of their choice.

On June 30, Minister of Education Stephen Lecce – in the company of Solicitor General Michael Kerzner and MPPs Patrice Barnes (Ajax), Robin Martin (Eglinton-Lawrence), and Laura Smith (Thornhill) – attended the Ledbury Jewish Centre in midtown Toronto to announce that the government has decided to fund subsidies to parents for cultural or faith-based daycare programs for their children without regard to the location of the school in relation to the home address of the family.

According to The CJN Minister Lecce said: “One of the great challenges that really rose to members of our government is that often governments create systems for bureaucracies, not for clients, not for families, and certainly not for the end user, the child.  (Our emphasis) We are going to allow portability in subsidies, we are going to give incentives to parents to choose the right child care for their family.”

(Our emphasis)

The Minister’s policy is sound. He affirms the essential principle cherished in our society that the highest priority of our education system is the best interests of the “end user”, i.e., the child. Moreover, Minister Lecce implies, emphatically we must add, that ensuring the best educational interest of the “end user” – the Ontario child – means enabling “parents to choose the right child care for their family.”

If we substitute the word “education” for the phrase “child care” in the minister’s announcement, we do not alter the principle that he so resolutely affirmed. Indeed, we affirm it further with deeper, truer meaning. For it is incontestable that the system of educating the child begins with appropriate daycare. Were this not the case, the announcement last week about the subsidies would have been made by another minister, perhaps the Minister for Children, Community and Social Services, or the Minister of Health. But, of course, the announcement was made by the Minister of Education.

The Solicitor General reinforced the inviolate principle concerning the best interests of the child when he added: “Faith-based child care that is accessible, that is equitable, is good for Ontario. It helps keep our families intact in the way that they practice their faith and maintain their culture.”

In enunciating this new educational policy, Minister Lecce and subsequently, the Solicitor General as well, echoed the preferred educational policy pronouncements by recognized educators and educational and social policy analysts. For example, in Funding All Students: A Comparative Economic Analysis of the Fiscal Cost to Support Students in Ontario Independent Schools, David Hunt, Anointing Momoh, and Deani Van Pelt (Cardus, September 2021) wrote the following:

“But as a morally formational good, parents have a prior and universal right to choose—and deeply personal interest in—their child’s education, and thus these public funds should follow families to their preferred school. Accordingly, funding is the norm around the world, as well as in Canada.”

To urge Ontario to follow the well-established international educational funding norm, the authors added: “Globally, 73 percent of countries at least partially fund independent schools—only one OECD country does not. In Canada outside Ontario, 75 percent of independent schools and 84 percent of independent-school students are partially publicly funded. Put differently, Ontario’s lack of funding is anomalous in both a global and Canadian context.” (Our emphasis)

Minister Lecce has unequivocally articulated the funding principle that anchors proper educational funding in advanced, modern western societies. Indeed, as Cardus has pointed out, that funding principle is the “norm around the world, as well as in Canada.”

But not in Ontario. Alas.

Minister Lecce acknowledged the importance and substantive soundness of that educational funding principle. The Solicitor General eloquently supported the core aspect of the principle. But it appears Ontario has no qualms in refusing to apply that principle to the 150,000 Ontario children who attend independent schools.

The CJN story is available at:

Ontario to make it easier for faith-based daycares to offer subsidies across city boundaries

•••

We still await the decision of Judge Papageorgiou on the motion brought by the governments of Ontario and Canada to strike our application. As soon as we know her decision, we will share it with you.

If you wish to support GAJE’s lawsuit for fairness in educational funding, please click here.

For further information, please contact Israel Mida at: imida1818@gmail.com

Charitable receipts for donations for income tax purposes will be issued by Mizrachi Canada. Your donations will be used for the sole purpose of underwriting the costs of the lawsuit.

•••

Shabbat shalom

Grassroots for Affordable Jewish Education (GAJE)

July 7, 2023

Two years ago, in July 2021, we wrote how “Ontario’s anachronistic, unfair, discriminatory educational funding policies” were attracting the attention of scholars and students at home and abroad. Specifically, we pointed to an essay by Prof. Randal F. Schnoor of the Koschitzky Centre for Jewish Studies at York University, entitled Jewish Education in Canada and the United Kingdom. Prof. Schnoor’s essay appeared in anthology No Better Home: Jews, Canada, and the Sense of Belonging, (University of Toronto Press, 2021) edited by Prof. David S. Koffman of York University.

Prof. Schnoor wrote about the funding of Jewish education throughout Canada – historically and currently. He paid particular attention to the day school situation in Greater Toronto, focusing on the crisis of affordability. In gathering the information for his essay, Prof. Schnoor relied upon information provided by GAJE.

Two months ago, Prof. Schnoor and Robert Brym, a professor of sociology and an associate of the Centre for Jewish Studies at the University of Toronto, co-edited The Ever-Dying People?:Canada’s Jews in Comparative Perspective, (University of Toronto Press, 2023).The book “compares Canada’s Jews with other Canadian ethnic and religious groups and with Jewish communities in other diaspora countries, including the United States, the United Kingdom, France, and Australia. It also sheds light on social divisions within Canadian Jewry: across cities, sub-ethnic groups, denominations, genders, economic strata, and political orientations.”

In addition to co-editing the work, Prof. Schnoor has authored one of the book’s essays, The Centrality of Jewish Education in Canada. Typically, he provides a well-researched, well-written, informative discussion about Canadian Jewry’s approach (historically and presently) to what it has always considered to be essential to developing our identity and to ensuring our survival, namely Jewish education.

In his discussion, Prof. Schnoor writes about the “affordablity crisis and response.” Once again, he refers to the work and to the writings of GAJE. We are proud to be part of this important discussion. But we are especially gratified to help enable the discussion among experts and scholars.

“While Jewish day schools and summer camps have a positive effect on Jewish identity, their cost is a barrier to access. Between 2001 and 2011 average household income in Toronto rose 11 per cent. Jewish elementary school tuition rose 61 per cent. The average elementary Jewish day school tuition in Toronto was $16,737 in 2019-20. (Grassroots for Affordable Jewish Education [GAJE] n.d.). This is a major financial commitment for non-affluent families, especially when there is more than one child attending school. The Jewish community provides substantial tuition subsidies for low-income families, but middle-class families are financially squeezed. (Brym and Lenton 2020; Kotler-Berkowitz, Ad let, and Kelman 2016). They may want their children to be exposed to Jewish life and culture and to develop a strong Jewish identity through Jewish schooling, but high and rising costs are prohibitive. When added to the onerous cost of home ownership in Toronto, especially in a Jewish neighbourhood, and maintaining a Jewish household and Jewish way of life, the cost of day school tuition is increasingly out of reach for many families.”

GAJE has been involved for more than 8 years in the discussion concerning the crisis in Ontario of the affordability of a Jewish education. We will remain involved, until the discussion can be closed with the knowledge that truly affordable Jewish education has been secured for Ontario families in perpetuity.

•••

We still await the decision of Judge Papageorgiou on the motion brought by the governments of Ontario and Canada to strike our application. As soon as we know her decision, we will share it with you.

If you wish to support GAJE’s lawsuit for fairness in educational funding, please click here.

For further information, please contact Israel Mida at: imida1818@gmail.com

Charitable receipts for donations for income tax purposes will be issued by Mizrachi Canada. Your donations will be used for the sole purpose of underwriting the costs of the lawsuit.

•••

Shabbat shalom

Grassroots for Affordable Jewish Education (GAJE)

June 30, 2023

It is that thankfully, annually recurring time of the year when most of our youngsters can contemplate a break from the grind and the routine of school. Summertime looms imminently for most children with the sweet promise of freer roaming through time and space. At least until September.

GAJE has used this space – because of the time of year – to commend, celebrate and thank everyone involved in the intricate, delicate-sturdy, immensely vital, superstructure of community education. The September-to-June discipline is not easy. We ought to acknowledge this.

• Our children, first and foremost. It is they, with egos and senses of self on the line, who pass through months of constant subtle and overt testing and evaluation,

• Teachers, school administrators, staff and volunteers. They design, run and maintain the educational superstructures of their respective schools and communities.

• Community professionals and philanthropists. They are the supportive backbone trying to ensure that the structures stand securely in perpetuity.

• Parents, grandparents and empathetic friends. They affirm, reinforce and embody the lessons their children learn every day, even as the parents – in most cases – bear the many-sided burdens of the heavy cost of sending their children to Jewish schools.

If it is true that “it takes a village to raise a child”, it is also true, if not also more emphatically so, that it takes a community to (Jewishly) educate a child. The late Lord Rabbi Jonathan Sacks eloquently explained why this is so and how it came to be. (We have reproduced this statement in the past. It is that important.)

“For Jews, education is not just what we know. It’s who we are. No people ever cared for education more. Our ancestors were the first to make education a religious command, and the first to create a compulsory universal system of schooling – eighteen centuries before Britain… the Egyptians built pyramids, the Greeks built temples, and the Romans built amphitheaters, Jews built schools. They knew that to defend a country you need an army, but to defend a civilization you need education. So, Jews became the people whose heroes were teachers, whose citadels were schools, and whose passion was study and the life of the mind.”

To defend, refine and perpetuate Jewish “civilization”, each generation of parents teaches their children how to live meaningful Jewish lives. Wherever Jews settled around the globe during the millennia, the community elders – leaders, sages, philanthropists, entrepreneurs and ordinary folk – ensured that a school would be built even before a synagogue was. The reason for this was obvious to most, but considered so important that it was enshrined in the 16th century, in the Shulchan Aruch (the settled code of Halachah). Jewish law required each community to ensure the presence of teachers in their midst because “the world exists only through the breath of school children.”

Exactly ten years ago this week in The Canadian Jewish News, the following observation was noted on the subject of the “breath of school children”, i.e., their voices, conversations, ideas, songs, squeals of laughter, or sobs of sadness.

“At a Grade One ceremony at the Associated Hebrew Schools in Toronto, headmaster Dr. Mark Smiley told a story about Rabbi Abraham Joshua Heschel, who, when asked what God sees when He looks in the mirror, answered that God sees the hopes, aspirations, prayers and possibilities of children.

We can surmise that Rabbi Heschel was telling us that it is for the sake of our children – of all children – that God created a world that they might embrace, cherish and strive always to protect. For one another and for all mankind. It is for this reason that we educate our children in the hope that they, in time, will choose to educate their own children for the same purpose.

And so, GAJE congratulates, commends, and thanks everyone involved in educating our children. Especially our children. May the summer be safe, happy and restorative for all of you.

•••

If you wish to contribute to GAJE’s lawsuit for fairness in educational funding, please click here.

For further information, please contact Israel Mida at: imida1818@gmail.com

Charitable receipts for donations for income tax purposes will be issued by Mizrachi Canada. Your donations will be used for the sole purpose of underwriting the costs of the lawsuit.

•••

Shabbat shalom

Grassroots for Affordable Jewish Education (GAJE)

June 23, 2023

This update is dedicated to the memory of Mira Koschitzky.

Mira devoted so many of her prodigious abilities and talents to enhancing the possibility of Jewish education for children near and far. Her passing last week has diminished our world. But recalling her life – her goodness, her values, her example and her unshakable belief in the importance of offering assistance where needed and of getting things done –strengthens us. Her memory will always be for blessing.

•••

It will be two months on Tuesday (June 20) since GAJE appeared in court to defend a motion by the governments of Ontario and Canada that sought to dismiss our lawsuit because, as they alleged, it discloses no cause of action. The governments preferred to try to pre-empt the courts from deliberating upon the issues we and the Ontario Federation of Independent Schools, who have received permission to join our application, maintain raise important legal and societal questions of fairness and justice in the year 2023. We, of course, plead with the courts to fully engage with the constitutional issues that comprise the core of our application for the sake of finding the best solution for the people of Ontario.

We are still waiting for the judge to render her ruling on the governments’ motion.

Waiting, however, can be somewhat disheartening. Doubt finds a way of intruding through the tiny portals of extended time. How will the judge decide? The question nags at us with each passing day. But since we cannot know the answer to this question, we cannot allow such doubt-in-small-nagging-doses to overturn our belief in the importance of GAJE’s cause or in the correctness of GAJE’s decision to resort to the courts to seek fairness and justice.

Fortuitously, this week’s Torah portion (Shelach Lecha) arrives at this juncture of awaiting the judge’s decision. It helps to abate the doubt.                                                 

Moses sends twelve scouts to reconnoitre the Promised Land. Ten of the twelve scouts provide a negative report of what they saw. They were overwhelmed by a lack of confidence and even by fear. Faced with what they considered to be a daunting, impossible task, the ten returning scouts cringed.  In sad, pathetic, self-deprecating language they explain to Moses that the inhabitants of the land saw them (the scouts) as “grasshoppers”, i.e., small inconsequential individuals.

But far worse, the ten scouts saw themselves as grasshoppers. “We were as grasshoppers in our own eyes.” (Numbers 13:33)

One need not be a psychologist to understand the defeat that will inexorably result from such low self-esteem. If we see ourselves as tiny, incapable, weak, flimsy and frail, others will too.

Trying to help ensure the affordability of Jewish education is a daunting task. Indeed, GAJE was formed more than 8 years ago for this single purpose. We hope that we are closer to our objective. But we cannot yet say that we are close. Nevertheless, we emphatically do not see ourselves as grasshoppers in this cause. Nor will we allow others to see us grasshoppers.

Despite the enormity of the task ahead of us, we are up to it. We will not back away. We acknowledge the difficulties ahead. They may even be giant difficulties. But we will go forward until there is no longer any path forward. This statement is not only descriptive of how GAJE sees itself in this struggle for fairness and justice. It is also prescriptive – a promise: We will not give up or give in. We do not see ourselves as grasshoppers.

•••

If you wish to contribute to GAJE’s lawsuit for fairness in educational funding, please click here.

For further information, please contact Israel Mida at: imida1818@gmail.com

Charitable receipts for donations for income tax purposes will be issued by Mizrachi Canada. Your donations will be used for the sole purpose of underwriting the costs of the lawsuit.

•••

Shabbat shalom

Grassroots for Affordable Jewish Education (GAJE)

June 16, 2023

The Canadian Jewish News (CJN) recently reported that the Torah Day School of Ottawa (TDSO) is offering families up to $100,000 to relocate to Ottawa.

According to The CJN the family receiving the funds must use them as part of a down payment on a house in Ottawa. The family must also commit to remain in Ottawa for a minimum of five years and to enrol their children in the TDSO. Families are eligible for the full $100,000 if they have two children attending Torah Day School in grades 1 to 8; $50,000 if they have one child in grades 1-8, and $25,000 for a child in kindergarten. Families must move to Ottawa between August 2023 and July 2024.

The hope of the originators and funders of the program is to further catalyse the growth of Ottawa’s Jewish community.

Kudos and full plaudits to the school and to the community’s leaders. The initiative is an innovative, generous, out-of-the-box effort by Torah Day School of Ottawa and indeed, the community’s leaders to grow their community.

But the key to the initiative and the reason we draw readers’ attention to it, is because of its reliance on the desire among so many young families to be able to provide an intense Jewish education to their children. Jewish education is the keystone holding firmly in place the arc of Jewish life. The initiative understands that Jewish education is the best guarantor of meaningful, engaged, inclusive, fulfilling Jewish life. In addition, it understands that Jewish education is a key to building community

Community-based measures aimed at making Jewish education more affordable for young families must be widely shared.

To learn more about the TDSO initiative go to:

https://www.torahday.ca/move-to-ottawa-100k-incentive-program

The CJN story is available at:

New incentive program is offering families up to $100,000 to move to Ottawa and enrol in day school

•••

If you wish to contribute to GAJE’s lawsuit for fairness in educational funding, please click here.

For further information, please contact Israel Mida at: imida1818@gmail.com

Charitable receipts for donations for income tax purposes will be issued by Mizrachi Canada. Your donations will be used for the sole purpose of underwriting the costs of the lawsuit.

•••

Shabbat shalom

Grassroots for Affordable Jewish Education (GAJE)

June 9, 2023

Andres Spokoiny, the president and CEO of Jewish Funders Network, is an insightful, creative thinker. He embraces broad ideas and looks thoughtfully to the horizons of Jewish life to anticipate coming storms and to sound the sheltering clarion.

In the recent edition of Sapir, the journal published by the Maimonides Fund that “explores the future of the American Jewish community,” Spokoiny proposed a large initiative, a “moonshot idea” in his words, to achieve universal basic Jewish literacy for as wide a swath as possible of North American Jews.

His proposal is radical given the unprecedented intra-and-inter-communal effort that would be required to make it happen. But it is quite on point as a response equal in measure to that of the approaching storm.

The intersection of Spokoiny’s suggestion with GAJE’s mission is obvious. Access to meaningful Jewish education for all who seek it, is the best way to ensure a thriving Jewish community into the future and in perpetuity.

Spokoiny makes his case with compelling logic. “For a culture to thrive, people need to truly know what that culture encompasses. To feel part of a historical continuum, people need to learn that history. To find comfort in rituals (regularly and at life’s key moments), people need to understand the ritual. To be guided by wisdom in ancient sources, people need to be able to navigate their structure and content beyond a handful of cherry-picked quotes. This requires sustained engagement with meaningful Jewish content.”

For discussion purposes, Spokoiny offers a framework of a “curriculum” of sorts. He acknowledges shortcomings, possible valid criticisms, and sundry other challenges. But he moves nevertheless, uncowed by difficulties, but rather energized by the importance and the scale of the proposal.

“A proper program of Jewish cultural literacy needs to cover the different areas that make up the fascinating kaleidoscope of religion, nationality, culture, and history that is Judaism. Scholars have argued extensively about what the pillars of Jewish content are, and many have debated what would make an educated Jew. But by and large, the fundamentals can be grouped into six buckets:

1. Rituals and practices
2. Texts and sources
3. History
4. Languages, art, and culture
5. Thought and philosophy
6. Zionism and Israel

Spokoiny proposes that “most adult Jews experience at least a hundred hours of Jewish studies, covering the basic building blocks of Jewish cultural literacy. This needs to be normative and transformative — a “Birthright Judaism” in its scale and some of its features. Just as Jews have a “birthright” to the Land of Israel, they also have a birthright to their culture and their multi-faceted heritage.”

The radical idealism of his proposal does not wash away Spokoiny’s accumulated experience or abiding sense of realism. “The biggest impediment to the success of this project, he writes, “will not be funding or organizational wherewithal, but motivation.”

Spokoiny is no dreamer. He is quite the pragmatist. He imagines the parameters of a path forward, while acknowledging the many stumbles that might happen along the way. But he understands the potential for the people of which he feels so fully, happily and proudly a member. “If this moonshot comes even close to fruition….it will provide a common foundation for people to have informed Jewish conversations. It will expose Jews to the richness of their culture, providing a valuable historical perspective to face the challenges of our time. It will empower them to use Jewish wisdom, sources, and ritual to find meaning. It will make them more likely to want to transmit that heritage to the next generation.”

Enabling Jews to transmit our heritage from one generation to the next is exactly GAJE’s purpose. May Spokoiny find a way – soon – to implement his moonshot idea.

Spokoiny’s article can be found at:

Universal Jewish Literacy

•••

If you wish to contribute to GAJE’s lawsuit for fairness in educational funding, please click here.

For further information, please contact Israel Mida at: imida1818@gmail.com

Charitable receipts for donations for income tax purposes will be issued by Mizrachi Canada. Your donations will be used for the sole purpose of underwriting the costs of the lawsuit.

•••

Chag Shavuot samayach. Shabbat shalom

Grassroots for Affordable Jewish Education (GAJE)

June 2, 2023

Three weeks ago, in his Dvar Torah for parshat Emor, Rabbi Jarrod Grover of Congregation Beth Tikvah spoke on the subject of rethinking public education. His presentation was substantive and timely and worthy of sharing with GAJE supporters and followers. It is especially appropriate to do so, on the eve of the holiday of Shavuot, the communal celebration of the giving of the Law at Mount Sinai.

The holiday begins this evening. It has always been associated with Jewish education for it is only through such education that we can fulfill the obligation – and our promise – to teach the laws, customs, traditions, ethics, folkways, and all their underlying values – to our children. And it is only by fulfilling our obligation – and promise – to educate our children that we can imbue them with aspects of the breadth and depth of those laws that were ordained at Mount Sinai and that have evolved in the subsequent 3500 years in order to anchor our mission to help perfect an imperfect world.

And so, we bring to readers’ attention to some of the key thoughts from Rabbi Grover’s Shavuot-appropriate, deeply relevant, message to his congregation three weeks ago.

•••

“I believe very strongly that Jewish day school education is the best tool I have at my disposal for instilling Jewish identity in my children, and ensuring Jewish continuity. I believe that it is my right as a Canadian parent to educate my children in my particular religious tradition. And I believe that it is unacceptable that in our province, Catholic education is fully funded to the exclusion of all other religious groups.

“But I also believe that Ontario, and Canada, needs a strong public education system with schools that educate students to contribute to the common good in various different ways. We should all want that. And we should all be concerned that so many parents feel that our system is not meeting their needs…..

“In our diverse and heterogeneous country, one-size-fits-all solutions for public education will become increasingly difficult to sustain, and increasing inappropriate for the needs of our children and their parents. ….

“[W]e in the Jewish community have a tremendous opportunity to partner with parents across the province in the rethinking of public education. We ought to support every effort to fund Jewish day schools, including the recent lawsuit being brought against the province. … But we ought also to set our sights higher – towards public funding for all schools – for all the diverse educational institutions that have been established so as to correspond to the diverse preferences of the people who live here. All schools – religious and secular, Catholic and independent, ought to be considered public schools that contribute to the public good, and to the development of a next generation of workers, neighbours, and voters with whom we will live and on whom we will depend to build a flourishing society. No parent should be forced to compromise their values and/or their finances in order to achieve a meaningful expression of their rights. This is a principle all of us can get behind.”

The Minister of Education ought to hear Rabbi Grover’s compelling message about Ontario’s educational system. Indeed, all Ontarians should. Its essential truth is one of fairness and justice. We agree with Rabbi Grover. “It is unacceptable in our province, that Catholic education is fully funded to the exclusion of all other religious groups.”

•••

If you wish to contribute to GAJE’s lawsuit for fairness in educational funding, please click here.

For further information, please contact Israel Mida at: imida1818@gmail.com

Charitable receipts for donations for income tax purposes will be issued by Mizrachi Canada. Your donations will be used for the sole purpose of underwriting the costs of the lawsuit.

•••

Chag Shavuot samayach. Shabbat shalom

Grassroots for Affordable Jewish Education (GAJE)

May 25, 2023

In November of 2022, Cardus – the public policy think tank – published a research paper entitled Naturally Diverse: The Landscape of Independent Schools in Ontario. The study provides current, detailed information on Ontario’s independent schools. GAJE brought this important report to the attention of our readers and supporters at the time it was published nearly 8 months ago and again earlier this year. It is a seminal work.

The authors of the study – David Hunt, Joanna Dejong Vanhof and Jenisa Los – perform an invaluable service. Their combined work deserves to be widely read. It provides factually unassailable data on the nature of Ontario’s independent schools and of their respective populations.

As we wrote, the information provided by Cardus’ researchers enables government officials to make public policy based upon fact, not upon myth. The study conclusively proves that independent schools are a multi-purpose, multi-faceted, multi-pedagogical tapestry of diverse families and students. They are definitely NOT a bastion of the elite. Only 61 of the 1,445 independent schools, namely 4.2% of the schools, can be classified as “top tier”.These 61 schools account for 16% of all students attending independent schools. The government can cast into the trash bin of debunked myths, the harmful, false notion that extending any funds to independent schools would provide taxpayer funds to the well-heeled families of the province’s elite schools.

Naturally Diverse can be found at:

https://www.cardus.ca/research/education/reports/naturally-diverse-the-landscape-of-independent-schools-in-ontario/

Last month, Kathryn Boothby, award-winning journalist and business writer, relied upon the study for an article for the National Post to chronicle the consistent growth of the independent school sector in Ontario. In the article entitled Explosive Growth in Schools, Boothby notes that there are some 1,445 independent schools in Ontario, an increase of over 50 per cent since 2013-14. She adds that “enrollment rose by almost 30,000 students, more than any other province in the country. Most recent numbers (2019-20) indicate independent schools in Ontario now educate over 154,000 students.”

Boothby describes the increase in the number of independent schools and in student enrollment from a number of points of view. Her article is quite instructive. However, we wish to highlight three key points from her article.

First: She notes that the sector is incredibly unique and diverse, with over 40 per cent having a specialization. Quoting David Hunt, she adds that “each school serves unique and specific student needs that district schools either don’t or can’t meet. More growth in the sector, and options to specialize, allows parents to self-select the type of school they believe is most beneficial for their child.”

Second: Boothby ties the information in Naturally Diverse to other recent Cardus from its complementary report, A Good Fit, which looked at the type of school a child attended versus how it affected outcomes. Again, quoting Hunt, “In an environment where students feel comfortable and familiar, there is a significant impact on student success. That is how important ‘fit’ is to academic outcomes. Civic engagement and career advancement also correlate with academic achievement. For a child to succeed, ‘fit’ matters,” Hunt said. There are hundreds of private schools that may offer a better fit for a child both socially and academically than the current public schools, Boothby adds.

Finally, quoting David Hunt, education director at Cardus and co-author of the report, she emphasizes that the increase in schools and student numbers “comes despite zero taxpayer funding for independent schools in Ontario, compared to Quebec and every province in the west.”

And so, we ask the provincial government – with as much pain and sorrow in our hearts as frustration and anger – why? Why, in the year 2023, should Ontario – the richest province in Canada – be the outlier? Why, in the year 2023, should Ontario be so indifferent to helping the more than 150,000 students attending independent schools achieve their best educational outcomes? Why, in the year 2023, should Ontario care nothing for fairness in educational funding?

The Boothby article is available at:

https://www.tabletmag.com/sections/news/articles/case-free-jewish-day-school

•••

If you wish to contribute to GAJE’s lawsuit for fairness in educational funding, please click here.

For further information, please contact Israel Mida at: imida1818@gmail.com

Charitable receipts for donations for income tax purposes will be issued by Mizrachi Canada. Your donations will be used for the sole purpose of underwriting the costs of the lawsuit.

•••

Shabbat shalom

Grassroots for Affordable Jewish Education (GAJE)

May 19, 2023